Injustice and Inaction: A Blog Post Disguised as a Book Review of The Buddha in the Attic

The Buddha in the Attic
The Buddha in the Attic by Julie Otsuka
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This was a quick, powerful read.

Written in the first-person plural, the story is at once personal and essentially anonymous. It is not the story of just one person, but of a people. The use of the “we” brings attention to the “us” vs “them” nature of racism and prejudice, and in the last chapter when the “we” changes, it raises the question, “Who are ‘we’ anyway?”

Otsuka takes us through the lives of picture brides from Japan, from their nervous but hopeful journey across the ocean to the harsh realities of their lives in America to their internment—along with their husbands and children and grandchildren—because they are deemed a threat to national security after Pearl Harbor.

In the group at which we discussed this book, the conversation turned to why it is that we, even today, avoid seeing violations of civil rights and prejudicial treatment going on around us. Why, we asked ourselves, do we as a culture turn away rather than acting when we see injustice?

We talked about the recession and how we’ve got our own stuff to worry about. We talked about how busy people are and how uninformed. We talked about the consolidation of media power and the resulting shallowness and one-sidedness of the news we consume. We talked about the compartmentalization that happens in social media and web searches and online bookstores that are designed to show us more of what already interests us. We talked about the lack of community.

This was a comfortable, philosophical approach to our inaction. What was less comfortable was when I turned the question on myself.

When I see an injustice, why don’t I act? I used to act. I used to get up in arms and demonstrate and write legislators and help set up panel discussions. Why don’t I any more?

It’s not that I’m uninformed. If anything, I think I’m better informed about issues than I was in my twenties during my activism heyday.

It’s not that I don’t care. Discussions at church about how the Ecuadorean population of a nearby town are being mistreated in the wake of a recent tragedy leave me in tears. I feel compelled to do something and yet when it comes time, I balk.

Why is this?

The only reason I can figure is fear. Fear of taking a stand, fear of arguing, fear of being yelled at. I have an introvert’s trepidation about meeting new people and talking in front of groups that’s just compounded by the fact that the “new people” are part of a foreign culture and many of them don’t speak my first (and pretty much only) language.

I realize, too, that I’m afraid of intensity of emotion.

I watch activists speaking and they can hardly talk, the words are all fighting to get out of their mouths at the same time. They cry frequently. Their passion is evident.

I used to share that passion. In my twenties and early thirties, if someone mentioned birth, I had that same flood of words that crowded in my mouth. I could—and would—argue hammer and tongs about the evils of episiotomies and the importance of teaching doctors how to deliver breech babies vaginally rather than relying on surgery.

But in the years since my son was born, my passion has cooled. And I do not miss it.

I’ve made peace with many of my feelings about birth, and I don’t want to go back to that out-of-control, all-consuming obsession with something I had little ability to change or even affect.

I’m enjoying the calm, and I’m afraid of getting pulled back into the intensity.

While I don’t think the out-of-control type of passion is necessary for activism, I don’t know how to be an activist without it. I want to be an equanimous activist. I want to stand in the river and let the current rush by me. But I’ve yet to figure out how to get into the river without the struggle, so I continue to stand on shore.

With all of the things I fear, the biggest is that if I were put to a moral test like those that so many faced during World War II, I would fail.

View all my reviews

NaNoWriMo Day 8 Word Count: 14,124

7 comments

  1. Pingback: Book Review: When the Emperor Was Divine by Julie Otsuka « Imperfect Happiness
  2. Pingback: 2011: My Year in Books « Imperfect Happiness
  3. Zoie @ TouchstoneZ · November 12, 2011

    Cr*p, CJ. I’m trying to avoid this moral question right now because I’m procrastinating on my OWS part 2 post. Now, you’ve got me thinking about my issues with in/activism again. Also, another book it sounds like I’ll add to my library list!

    Like

  4. Jamie @ I am totally that mom · November 10, 2011

    I never cease to be amazed how you seem to take things straight from my head and write so eloquently about them.

    I also used to be much more of an activist consumed by that passion. Sometimes I wonder why I’ve dulled, but other times I’m just thankful to let things go. I don’t think my heart can take the intensity of those emotions right now as I struggle with depression and anxiety, though at the same time, I feel like I am just turning part of myself off in an attempt to cope. Sometimes I think I’ve gotten older and wiser to not get so fired up about everything, and other times I think I’ve just let a part of myself die, or maybe not die but lay comatose for now. It’s an internal struggle to both want to hold onto those ideals and know I am standing for everything I believe in and yet want to find some sort of peace and calm.

    Like

    • CJ · November 10, 2011

      Thank you for your kind comment, Jamie. I think at some point, we just have to meet ourselves where we are. If activism isn’t our thing right now, that’s just where we are. I perform quiet, everyday actions to support my ideals, and I do my best to be compassionate to everyone, especially those with whom I disagree. It’s possible that practicing compassion might be a more powerful type of activism than any of the impassioned arguing I did in my younger days. And I maintain the hope that, if a situation requiring action on my part arises, I will be ready to take that action.

      Like

  5. Anonymous Me · November 9, 2011

    Firstly, I really enjoy reading your reviews! You are so much more succinct than I think I would be…but I am thinking of giving them a shot next year. šŸ™‚ Secondly, and somewhat unrelated to this particular post…I have a strange question to ask. Would it be ok if I mentioned you in a blog post? I started thinking about the blog buddies I have, and whether or not we’d get along ‘in real life’. This has led me to want write a post about how I think of myself vs how I think others think of me. If it would bother you *at all*, I won’t include you, but given that you/your blog in particular were the impetus for the idea I would like to. Once I write it, it may be total crap that I don’t end up posting, but I thought I would ask just in case. Let me know what you think. šŸ™‚

    Like

    • CJ · November 9, 2011

      I would be pleased to be mentioned in a blog post of yours. As long as you weren’t saying mean things, which I wouldn’t anticipate (although I have been known to wear yoga pants as pants in public, and I know you have strong feelings about that). I look forward to reading what you write about this. It’s something I’ve wondered, too.

      And thanks for the compliment on my reviews! They’re not my most popular posts, but I keep posting them anyway because they have a small but loyal following.

      Like

Your turn! What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s