Proving I Don’t Care About My Blog Stats: Another Book Review

Little House on a Small Planet, 2nd: Simple Homes, Cozy Retreats, and Energy Efficient Possibilities
Little House on a Small Planet, 2nd: Simple Homes, Cozy Retreats, and Energy Efficient Possibilities by Shay Salomon
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

While I marked this book as “read”, in reality I skimmed it. It’s interesting enough and well-written enough that it could be a cover-to-cover read. I set out to read it that way, but since we just bought a house in the suburbs three months ago, I could’t bring myself to do any more than skim it.

Things I liked:

The approach. The book got me thinking about what “home” means to me and the way in which I use the spaces in my home.

The profiles. Seeing the variety of people who choose small houses and the variety of living situations of those living in smaller houses gave me a sense of the possibilities for my family at different stages in our lives. I also found it comforting when people moved from a small house into a larger one until their kids moved out and then moved back to a smaller house. It helped me feel a little better about our “bigger” house (our house isn’t huge, but I was hoping to keep it closer to 1000 square feet. We’re closer to 2000. *sigh* I know…horrible problem to have, whine, whine).

The floorplans. I am a sucker for floorplans. I wonder sometimes if I ought to have been an architect. Or perhaps just a person who does architectural drawing. I loved that class in junior high. The good old T square and I were good buddies.

The history. I knew houses were smaller back in the day, but I didn’t really understand how that worked in real life. How do you raise four children in 850 square feet? This book helped me get a better sense of that. (Less bathing, more time outside, family bed.)

Things I didn’t like:

-The author seems to assume a baseline level of practical ability and home building/improvement practices. Small house living doesn’t seem to be for the all-thumbs neophyte. Even if you’ve got a pre-built home and you don’t plan to mold it from mud and straw yourself, you still need to have some level of know-how to, you know, put in a loft or rig a system for elevating your dehydrated apple slices. The suggestion to “go vertical” requires some knowledge of how to build a stable structure that goes upwards. Between my husband and me, even choosing paint colors is beyond our combined abilities. When we move into a house, the walls stay just the way they were when we moved in. In fact, everything stays just the way it was. I even base where I hang photos on where there are already nails in the walls. If something—anything—breaks, we have to hire someone to fix it. We even had to hire someone to get an interior door to stop sticking. We have one here that won’t even close all the way, but since we’ve not yet found a handy-person in our new town, we just leave it ajar all the time. We are seriously inept.

-The majority of the small houses were in areas where the climate allows for at least some level of year-round outdoor living. A small house in New England would mean something different than a small house in southern Arizona. (No outdoor shower, for one thing.)

I guess that’s all I didn’t like about the book. It really was quite good, and I can see myself using some of the insights as I choose how to use the space we have in our current home. I can also see myself picking it back up next time we go to move into a new home. Who knows…maybe by then my husband or I will have acquired some practical skills. It could happen.

View all my reviews

5 comments

  1. Pingback: 2011: My Year in Books « Imperfect Happiness
  2. timbra · November 9, 2011

    Hmmmm. . . maybe a read for me? I do think if 1) we had a garage for our vehicle and things like BIKES (instead of having to store a tricycle, a scooter, a big wheel and a balance bike in the same room we consider the play and craft and laundry room) and our car (especially in the winter) would change my view of my house. A better layout would also change my perspective on this same square footage and finally. . . . if someone could just drywall and paint for me, this lame paneling also makes me feel icky. . . otherwise, i do see the wisdom in a smaller space. and in fact, i feel opposite of the big house now, small house later. I think small house now, while i want to be close (in all ways) with my kids and big house later, when i want my kids to come visit, with their own families. . . . i don’t think we’ll want to practice a family bed at that point 🙂

    Like

    • CJ · November 9, 2011

      I think you might really like this book, Timbra. The house I liked best was the “Grow Home” duplex that has its supporting walls on the perimeter so you can move the interior walls to change the layout as your family changed. Those are in Montreal. Everything awesome is in Canada. Except us.

      Like

  3. Jackie Paulson (Author) · November 9, 2011

    Great review! Expressed very well too.

    Like

    • CJ · November 9, 2011

      Thanks, Jackie! I appreciate all feedback, but especially praise. 🙂

      Like

Your turn! What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s