Book Review: The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan

The Lightning Thief
The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The Lightning Thief is kind of a cross between Harry Potter and American Gods.

Greek gods haven’t gone anywhere in the past several thousand years. They’ve been around the whole time and still up to their same old business mingling with mortals and spawning demigods. Luckily, there’s a special summer camp for these demigods. When they’re middle-schoolers and monsters start coming after them (sounds like middle school to me), they get the option of heading out to summer camp on Long Island, where they canoe and practice archery and run footraces and learn sword fighting and practice battling monsters.

My seven-year-old came in to say goodnight to me while I was reading it, and she read over my shoulder for a little while.

“It’s about Greek gods,” she said. I was impressed that she’d noticed the names and placed them so quickly.

She started asking more questions about the things she was reading where I had the book open, but I deflected her.

“It’s kind of confusing when you’ve not been reading the whole story,” I explained. “It will make more sense when we read it together.”

I’m not sure how long it will be before I think she’s ready for this series, though. This first book, at least, is pretty good, but it’s also pretty violent. There’s betrayal and swordplay and monsters and other scary stuff. And there’s this sense of mortals being stupid and oafish and the world being a dangerous and scary place, which I’m not sure is the best message for a child rather prone to anxiety anyway. Of course, she’s currently reading a kid version of Beowulf, so she’d probably be fine with that kind of thing. And she might really enjoy the idea of satyrs and centaurs and being able to talk with animals.

In addition, it feels maybe a little basic. Defeating the monsters seemed a little too easy and the schemes of the immortals a little too simple for my taste and, even worse, the characters seem a little flat. Their actions didn’t always seem to match what Riordan was saying their personality was. Their motives were difficult to figure out. I suppose I ought to cut the book a little slack since it’s meant for kids and I’m a jaded grown-up, but I don’t think that fact that it’s intended for children is a good excuse for flat characters.

But it’s better than the Magic Treehouse series, and I’m letting her read those. Maybe we’ll start on these sooner rather than later and see how it goes. I’m sure her dad would love to read these stories with her.

View all my reviews

5 comments

  1. Pingback: 2012: My Year in Books « Imperfect Happiness
  2. Abigail vR · June 15, 2012

    When I was reading the Magic Treehouse series to N I got to a point where I thought being poked in the eye would be better.

    I read all of the Percy Jackson books and Niels did too. We both liked them.

    Like

    • CJ · June 15, 2012

      Glad to hear I’m not the only one irritated by Magic Treehouse. We get the audiobooks from the library, so while I get to hear them, I don’t have to read them. Which is something, I guess. And my daughter and I get to discuss what makes a well developed story (and what doesn’t).

      Like

  3. Melanie Meadors · June 14, 2012

    I had been wondering what the “level” was for these books. Elijah expressed interest in reading them after his cousin had been talking about them, but his cousin is a couple years older and in public school, so has been exposed to a different set of things. Right now we are reading the Chronicles of Prydain, which Elijah likes a lot.

    Like

    • CJ · June 15, 2012

      I’ll have to look into The Chronicles of Prydain. Does it come with a pronunciation guide? We tried reading a couple of books of Celtic fairy tales recently and it seems I’m pretty lost when it comes to Welsh pronunciations.

      Like

Your turn! What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s